Building your next leadership team is something you have to take seriously. That sounds obvious, I know. But it’s easy to treat it as a project you hand off — to HR, to a search firm, to a consultant like me. But this needs to be visibly owned at the top — the CHRO owns it and the rest of the C-suite supports it and lives it. Not in a memo. In how they spend their time, who they bring into the room, and how much they’re willing to show people about the way the room actually works. The companies that do this well treat it as a personal priority, not a process. They might lean on outside advice, and they should. But they don’t outsource the thing itself.
You can keep it light. While taking it seriously.
Taking it seriously doesn’t mean making it heavy. There is judgment for the team leaders, and there is a responsibility to look out for the emotional health of the team — both of those are real. But don’t make it a group therapy session. People don’t like that. Most people don’t want to bare their souls at work, and they shouldn’t have to. What you want is easy ways for people to say what they wish were different. Some clients have done things like an actual tip jar, and part of the culture was that you could put in light ones and heavier ones. Somebody wants better coffee, somebody thinks the Monday meeting is a waste of everyone’s time, somebody is worried about how the last reorganisation was handled. Of course, the critical part is how you handle each of those. The coffee is easier than the reorg, but the conversation should be just as public. (I didn’t say this stuff was easy.)
Not everyone who can do the job well wants to do it at all
First of all, there’s something fairly basic to your next gen candidates that I’ve seen more than one client miss. They had identified candidates they felt really good about. And that is great. One hiccup — they hadn’t asked any of them if they wanted it.
Being good at the job doesn’t make the job more fun, less hard, or easier at its core. And as I wrote here, the C-suite life is one you have to prepare for. And the most capable people may not want to deal with the rest of what comes with being in that room. Because it’s a whole other kind of messy.
It’s important to see if the people you imagine running the organisation, want to feature in your future. It is worth learning whether a no is to any organisation, or yours. In other words, do they not want to be in the C-suite anywhere, or can’t imagine doing so where they are now. You don’t have to dig in — maybe you know your company is not for everyone and it’s a fair but tolerable answer. But, for some leadership teams, it’s valuable information if some of your most promising talent is turning away.
Introduce the future leaders to the present.
One thing current C-suite members have to remember is the environment is different and everyone in the room is used to it, assuming they’ve been in seat for some time. When you introduce a next gen candidate into that environment it’s easy to blindside them. One, the C-suite member has likely forgotten how stark the difference is. So they don’t warn. They also forget how unsettling the realisation is so they can be unprepared for the reaction. So first things first, be honest that the space is different. That’s the problem with being at the top. Every other level has someone senior. Now you’re in the room that has no stairs. This is the top. You don’t get to dump problems too hard to figure out on someone else. You are about to be the ultimate someone else.
It doesn’t mean the room is toxic. But it means the room is tense, the stakes are high, people build alliances (you call it politics, I call it people), and people feel passionate because it’s a decision they have to live with and manage. There’s a lot happening and a lot of it isn’t being said out loud. So, yes, a heads up to the person who just got there is in order. Tell them it’s ok to be overwhelmed. You’re exposing them to the room, not asking them to be comfortable in it.
Peel back the curtain, but don’t blindside future leaders.
So how much do you pull back the curtain, and when, and for whom? My suggestion is bring people in selectively. But, do it earlier than feels comfortable. Realistically people need two or three years to be built for that environment, and not just the skills — their personality and their strengths and how they hold up in it.
One client wanted his C-suite to be a locker room behind closed doors. Yell, curse, say what you want, and then be united in front of everyone. (I’m not endorsing that, I’m simply acknowledging that the attitude was a desire for people to be open behind closed doors.) And if that is truly the way the room operates, you have to be transparent about it, and you must have people who can thrive in it.
But that’s probably not the whole room. The locker room comes out in specific tough moments, and there are usually counterbalancing moments too, some organic, some planned — the CEO with a smaller group, or one to one with each of the C-suite, whatever. Something keeps that company a functional, productive organisation, and with all due respect to that CEO, I doubt constant locker room style comms is the entire story. (And technically, even actual locker rooms are not constant yelling and cursing, but that’s for another day.)
So bring the next gen into the calmer room first. Then, if it’s appropriate, into a louder one. And talk them through it. There is no penalty for cursing and yelling in here. There IS one for letting it leak into the larger organisation.
There’s a phrase about the farmer’s breakfast — the chicken is involved, but the pig is committed. I’m not suggesting being in the C-suite is as catastrophic as the pig’s role, of course. But people need to know what they are committing to really, not in concept. Most people think being in charge would be great… because they are not in charge. I think some of your best candidates are not the ones who say yes, I am fully in, but maybe those who say can you tell me more about it first.
Don’t just find your next gen talent. Start helping them live their future.
Getting your next generation team is a series of steps, and it should be a multiyear plan, not a sprint. First of all, building the next leadership team is a job for the top of the house, not something you hand off. Keep it light, but take it seriously. Ask your candidates if they actually want it — and if they don’t, find out whether it’s the job or it’s you. Then bring them in, earlier than feels comfortable. But, start them in the calmer room first, and then remind them of that when they go into the locker room version. Talk them through what they’re seeing. They won’t be fully ready. But they’ll have rehearsed. And you’ll both know a lot more about whether this is a future they want to be part of.

